The winner has been announced, but a wave of backlash over the final vote has cast a long shadow over the “American Idol” finale, with fans rallying behind a different favorite.
On Sunday, May 18, 2025, “American Idol” announced Jamal Roberts as the winner of season 23, sparking a buzz.
In a post shared on the show’s official Facebook page, Roberts was pictured smiling while holding his two young daughters and a winner’s gift hamper. The post celebrated his victory and marked the end of this season’s competition.
While Roberts secured the title, his win stirred strong reactions among viewers, many of whom voiced support for runner-up John Foster. The debate quickly took over social media platforms, with some viewers expressing disappointment and frustration.
On Instagram, several fans shared their thoughts, with one writing, “Eh. John should have won.” Another commented, “John was robbed,” while a third added, “Another rigged season.”
View this post on Instagram
Facebook comments echoed similar sentiments. One person wrote, “John should have won. He was so natural. Jamal screams to [sic] much.”
View this post on Instagram
Another said, “I really think John should have won. We need a good old fashioned country singer. They will all move on, all off them were great [sic].”
Some expressed stronger discontent. A fan shared, “John Foster got robbed. I will not watch next season.” Another quipped, “Yeah, it should have been John Foster cause he’s definitely better [sic].”
View this post on Instagram
Still, not all comments were critical. One person acknowledged both finalists, stating, “They’re both going places. Congratulations Jamal. Now John Foster isn’t bound to American Idol contract [sic].”
According to Roberts’ Instagram profile, he is not only a singer but also a father to two daughters named Harmoni and Lyriks.
View this post on Instagram
The reaction to this season’s result has fueled widespread discussion online. While Roberts moves forward as the official winner, many fans continue to debate the outcome, particularly in support of Foster.
But viewer reactions this season haven’t been limited to the finalists. Earlier in the competition, Carrie Underwood’s guest appearance drew its own wave of scrutiny, as several fans criticized her judging style and even called for her replacement next season.
Underwood embraced a fairytale vibe ahead of the May 12 “American Idol” episode, channeling Rapunzel in a striking purple gown with a modern twist. The dress featured a dramatic thigh-high slit and delicate floral embroidery along the front, blending elegance with bold flair.
Her long blonde hair flowed all the way down to her silver stilettos, accented with purple flower accessories that added an extra touch of enchantment. Underwood shared the look on Instagram with the caption, “It’s a #DisneyNight fit check! #CUonIDOL,” just before the Disney-themed episode aired.
That night, the top five contestants performed twice, once with a heroes-themed song and once as a villain, all vying for America’s vote.
While Underwood’s dress drew attention for its whimsical nod to Rapunzel, many viewers were more focused on her judging. Her critiques sparked a flurry of reactions online.
One blunt viewer didn’t mince words, penning, “Get rid of her. Her bias is showing.” Frustration continued as another viewer shared, “I wish it was a way to vote you off 🙄 Definitely plays favorites and it’s cringey to watch [sic].”
Among the critics, one conflicted fan expressed, “I love Carrie but this outfit was not it! And why critiquing Jamal so harshly? when the other guys do the same things that he does…he’s incredible! And i’m so shocked that Gabby was sent home [sic].”
An individual echoed a similar concern, “Yep she definitely didn’t like Jamal.” A viewer even appealed for changes, “Jelly Roll pleaseeeeee [sic]she’s got to go!” A disheartened fan didn’t hold back their disappointment, saying, “I hope you don’t be a judge on this show again you bring fake energy. Please don’t come back [sic].”
However, some viewers were quick to defend the judge, with one fan encouraging her, “You’re still going to get criticized, so you might as well do whatever you want 💫 ❤️🔥😸.”
Another admirer praised her, “Loved you as a judge this year. People don’t realize that you are dressed as Rapunzel tonight ….so much hate in this world. Love you, Carrie.”
Finally, someone else chimed in with a hopeful message, “Carrie I enjoyed watching you as a judge on American Idol, this year!I hope you come back year!![sic]”
On the night Carrie Underwood faced sharp criticism from viewers, host Ryan Seacrest guided the evening as she joined fellow judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan in narrowing the competition to its top three finalists. Slater Nalley and Thunderstorm Artis were eliminated after delivering two performances each.
Nalley sang “You’ve Got a Friend in Me” from “Toy Story” and “Born to be Wild” from “D3: The Mighty Ducks,” while Thunderstorm performed “A Dream Is a Wish Your Heart Makes” from “Cinderella” and “Find Yourself” from “Cars.”
Advancing to the finale were Foster, Roberts, and Breanna Nix. Foster performed “The Bare Necessities” from “The Jungle Book” and “Rainbow Connection” from “The Muppet Movie.”
Roberts impressed with “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough” from “Remember the Titans” and “Beauty and the Beast” from the classic film of the same name. Breanna moved forward after singing “This Will Be (An Everlasting Love)” from “The Parent Trap” and “You’ll Be in My Heart” from “Tarzan.”
As the season wrapped with memorable performances and unexpected turns, both the finale results and guest appearances left viewers divided, keeping the conversation around “American Idol” very much alive.
